7 S&W Model 69 Problems And Solutions

If you found yourself using the S&W Model 69 revolver, “What are its potential problems?”. As a firearm enthusiast, I’m here to help.

Smith & Wesson 69 L-Frame revolver is built to suit the demands of most defense needs. With a durable frame and 5-round cylinder, every gun user will be blown away by the feel of this gun immediately.

Let me cut to the chase and walk you through 7 S&W Model 69 problems and solutions. 

Here are S&W model 69 problems and solutions

I recommend reading the article in full if it’s your first time. But if you want the condensed version, read my key takeaways in the table. 

Problems	Solutions
Recoil management	Tight and correct grip, proper stance, and always being prepared.
Cylinder jamming	Clean the cylinder with the right solvent, and lubricate the cylinder with gun oil.
Trigger pull problems	Clean and lubricate the cylinder mechanism, polish the contact points of the trigger mechanism, and replace the most critical parts.
Shooting inaccurately	Clean the barrel properly with a bore brush and solvent. Make the barrel straight and secure. The rear and front sights should line up properly to hit the bullseye.
Firing pin issues	Replace the firing pin, spring, and all damaged parts.
Unaligned ball detent	Proper care and maintenance through timely servicing.
Faulty ejector	Clean the rod to get rid of any debris from the ejector star.

You can use the SPIKA Hunting Backpack with Rifle Holder to carry your M69 and other gun accessories.

1. Recoil management 

One problem the S&W Model 69 users complain about is recoil management. Although I believe the recoil boils down to the mind of the shooter, this revolver gave me a seamless experience while firing a .44 special.

However, the model is unpleasant if you’re shooting a full-bore .44 Magnum. You can use it as your backup, however.

With the 69, the cylinder will stop disengaging during the recoil, allowing the cylinder to rotate. This is the primary issue users have raised in the Smith and Wesson Forums.

The problem causes live rounds to be skipped. For someone like me who likes to shoot while their elbows, wrists, and shoulders are entirely flexed and relaxed, the 69 will cause trouble.

You’ll absolutely have an uncomfortable shooting experience.

Solution

The S&W Model 69 is arguably one of the most powerful handguns, so managing its recoil requires you to familiarize yourself with the best recoil control techniques.

The .44 Magnum round can deliver a hefty kick if you’re unprepared. Here are some of the tips to tame the recoil:

• Have a tight and correct grip. Make sure you have a solid hold on the grip before firing. A tight grip will transfer more recoil into your wrist and arm. Place your dominant hand high on the grip, wrapping your fingers around as much of the grip as possible. Support your dominant hand with your non-dominant hand.
• Proper stance. Stand with your feet shoulder-width apart, one foot slightly ahead of the other. Having a wide, balanced stance as you bend your knees will help absorb the recoil. Lean into the shot as you fire.
• Anticipation (be prepared). Being prepared for the recoil minimizes how much it affects your aim as well as follow-up shots. Know that the recoil is coming, so expect it with each shot. You should always take a breath and focus on a smooth trigger pull.

With practice and the proper technique, you’ll gain proficiency in managing the recoil of your Model 69.

2. Cylinder jamming/lookup

The Model 69 is a great revolver but can have issues, especially as it ages. If not maintained properly, the cylinder can sometimes fail to lock up securely. This is when the cylinder won’t rotate freely.

I discovered that this malfunction is usually caused by built-up grime that prevents the cylinder from turning properly.

Solution

The best solution to this issue is to thoroughly clean your Model 69. Ensure your gun is unloaded, then use a cleaning solvent, like Hoppes no. 9, and a bronze bore brush to scrub out each chamber in the cylinder.

• Clean the cylinder stop notch and cylinder stop plunger
• Lubricate the cylinder with gun oil

With regular cleaning and maintenance, you can prevent cylinder binding and keep your Model 69 running smoothly.

3. Trigger pull problems

Some shooters might find the double-action trigger pull gritty. Once you pull the trigger slowly, it will feel heavy and less smooth.

If the trigger feels stiff when you pull it, this is usually due to built-up debris in the mechanism. I experienced a jammed trigger after pulling it to the back when shooting. 

Solution

To address this recurring issue, thoroughly clean the trigger assembly with a quality gun solvent. Consider removing any built-up lead, powder, or primer residue.

• Clean the cylinder as well.
• Lubricate the trigger mechanism (use gun oil).
• Polish the contact points of the trigger mechanism with very fine-grade steel wool.
• If the issue persists, replace the parts or hire a qualified gunsmith.

Once you’re done, test the trigger pull. By now, it should feel smooth and consistent. Remember that this problem can negatively impact the gun’s accuracy and consistency.

4. Firing pin issues

If your Model 69 has misfire issues, the firing pin assembly is the most likely culprit. The firing pin is under much pressure each time you pull the trigger.

This leads to issues over time. The most common are:

• A broken firing pin. After thousands of rounds, the firing pin can become bent, blunted or even snap in half. This prevents it from striking the primer hard enough, causing misfires.
• Firing pin drag. The firing pin’s channel can become rough, causing the pin to stick or drag. This also leads to light strikes.
• Weakened firing pin spring. The spring provides the force that drives the firing pin forward. If it breaks, the firing pin won’t have enough power behind it.

Solution

Don’t keep pulling the trigger, hoping it will go away. Here are tips for troubleshooting firing pin problems.

• Replace the firing pin to get your revolver working again.
• Replace the spring.
• Hire a gunsmith to polish the channel out before your next range trip.
• Replace any broken or worn parts.

5. Shooting inaccurately

Another complaint about the S & W 69 Model is inaccurate shooting. A few issues could be the cause. They include:

• A buildup of residue in the barrel from shooting. After a few cylinders, carbon and lead can accumulate, throwing off your aim.
• Misaligned barrel or sight. This may result from the repeated drops that bend the barrel slightly, making shots go off target.
• Improper stance and grip while firing.

All these are the most likely culprits of the accuracy you get when firing with your L-frame revolver.

Solution

• Scrub the barrel with a bore brush and solvent.
• Make sure the barrel is straight and secure
• Ensure the rear and front sights line up properly to hit the bullseye.
• Have a firm and consistent two-handed grip, arms extended.
• Keep your stance balanced and still.

Mostly, accuracy problems with the model 69 revolver result from one of these easily remedied issues.

If cleaning the barrel, adjusting the sights, and improving your technique don’t help, seek help from a gunsmith. It will be worth your time if you want to hit the mark quickly.

6. Unaligned ball detent

Another problem that develops on your S&W model 69 is the unaligned ball detent. This is the spring-loaded bearing that holds the cylinder in place.

I found out that if it becomes misaligned or stuck, it won’t properly lock the cylinder for firing. The ball detent needs adjustment if the cylinder doesn’t lock.

Solution

Proper care and maintenance are the solution to this problem. Knowing when it’s time for professional servicing also helps keep your S&W model 69 revolver in top condition for many years.

7. Faulty ejector

In some cases, the ejector rod might back out slightly while shooting, causing issues with cylinder rotation. Simply put, this mechanism pushes spent cartridges out of the cylinder.

After extended use, the ejector rod can become clogged with dirt, grime, and carbon buildup. You’ll find out that cartridges won’t drop free per your expectations.

Solution

To fix this, fully unload your M69 and use a cleaning rod to get rid of any debris from vital parts, including the ejector star and cylinder.

You need to replace the damaged ejector rod, too. And lastly, regular checks help prevent this problem.

Is S&W model 69 worth having despite its problems?

That said, you should proudly own a Smith & Wesson Model 69 revolver. It’s the more concealable gun you ask for.

Although every firearm has good and bad sides, M69’s pros outweigh its cons. It delivers strong firepower for hunting or target shooting.

You’re good to go as long as you know the potential issues with this model, which can be fixed.

The Model 69 is a solid, well-built revolver. You only need to understand how to properly maintain it to have years of enjoyment in the field.

3 best S&W Model 69 alternatives in 2024

If your S&W model 69 fails, here are the best alternatives you can rely on:

Smith and Wesson 329 PD

The Smith & Wesson 329 PD is known for its firing power, making it ideal for backcountry carry.

Its Scandium alloy frame significantly reduces weight, making it more comfortable for long treks.

The gun features light-gathering red dots and adjustable sights.

Chambered in a .44 Magnum, it packs a punch, but be prepared for substantial recoil. The grip is ergonomically designed, though some might find it a bit small.

Overall, it is a reliable choice for those needing stopping power without the weight.

Taurus 44 Tracker

Taurus Tracker .44 Magnum is another interesting revolver on the market. It has a 4-inch ported barrel, weighs 35 ounces when unloaded, a 5.3-inch height, a 9-inch overall length, and a 1.6-inch wide.

One thing I love about this machine is that it sits on the hand very well. And it’s very stable on target.

Ruger Redhawk .44 Magnum

Another robust alternative to the S&W Model 69 is Ruger’s Redhawk. This revolver offers a smooth trigger and a comfortable grip. Its stainless-steel construction ensures durability, serving you for many years to come.

Frequently Asked Questions

What frame is the S&W Model 69?

L-frame. It’s a strong, durable frame built for continuous magnum usage. As an avid hunter, I can attest that this firearm withstands heavy use.

What is the oldest Smith & Wesson gun?

The Smith & Wesson Model 1.

What is the difference between Model 69 and 69 Combat Magnum?

Model 69 comes with a 4.25-inch barrel while a Combat Magnum version, which is more concealable, has a barrel length of 2.75-inch.

What frame size is a S&W Model 69?

A standard 1.56-inch-wide L-frame cylinder. Smith & Wesson has been improving the L-frame with a new short-barreled edition.

Now we have the Model 69 Combat Magnum that comfortably holds 5 rounds of .44.

How much does the S&W model 69 cost?

It costs around $915.

What type of manufacturer warranty is provided with the S&W model 69?

General lifetime service warranty.

What type of grips does the S&W model 69 have?

Synthetic grips. The grips provide a comfortable and secure hold on the firearm.

What are the building materials of the S&W model 69?

A combination of stainless steel and various other materials.